<tei:TEI xmlns:tei="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" rend="jTEI">
   <tei:teiHeader>
      <tei:fileDesc>
         <tei:titleStmt>
            <tei:title type="main">Disciplining Love and Care in the Nineteenth-Century German
               Kindergarten</tei:title>
            <tei:author>
               <tei:name>
                  <tei:forename>Nisrine</tei:forename>
                  <tei:surname>Rahal</tei:surname>
               </tei:name>
               <tei:idno type="ORCID">0009-0002-9374-7332</tei:idno>
            </tei:author>
         </tei:titleStmt>
         <tei:publicationStmt>
            <tei:publisher>BBF | Bibliothek für Bildungsgeschichtliche Forschung des
               DIPF</tei:publisher>
            <tei:date>2024</tei:date>
            <tei:availability>
               <tei:licence target="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/">
                  <tei:p>For this publication a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs
                     4.0 International license has been granted by the author(s) who retain full
                     copyright.</tei:p>
               </tei:licence>
            </tei:availability>
            <tei:idno type="DOI">10.25658/pd90-c591</tei:idno>
         </tei:publicationStmt>
         <tei:seriesStmt>
            <tei:title>Jahrbuch für Historische Bildungsforschung</tei:title>
            <tei:biblScope unit="volume">30</tei:biblScope>
         </tei:seriesStmt>
         <tei:sourceDesc>
            <tei:p>Jahrbuch für historische Bildungsforschung, Band 30, 2024</tei:p>
         </tei:sourceDesc>
      </tei:fileDesc>
      <tei:encodingDesc>
         <tei:projectDesc>
            <tei:p>Die Gründung des Jahrbuchs für Historische Bildungsforschung wurde im Mai 1991
               auf der Jahrestagung der Historischen Kommission der Deutschen Gesellschaft für
               Erziehungswissenschaft (DGfE), der Vorgängerin der Sektion Historische
               Bildungsforschung, beschlossen. Veröffentlicht werden Beiträge aus dem Gesamtgebiet
               der Historischen Bildungsforschung, wobei vor allem auch die Nachbardisziplinen zur
               Mitarbeit eingeladen sind. Historische Bildungsforschung wird hier als
               interdisziplinäres Feld verstanden, in das Fragestellungen der Erziehungs-,
               Geschichts- und Literaturwissenschaft ebenso Eingang finden wie die historische
               Anthropologie, historische Berufsbildungsforschung oder die Geschichte der Medien,
               der Geschlechter, der Kindheit und der Jugend.</tei:p>
            <tei:p>Das Jahrbuch für Historische Bildungsforschung wird von der Sektion Historische
               Bildungsforschung in Verbindung mit der BBF | Bibliothek für Bildungsgeschichtliche
               Forschung des DIPF | Leibniz-Institut für Bildungsforschung und Bildungsinformation
               herausgegeben. Den Kreis der Herausgeber:innen bilden 15 Wissenschaftler:innen, die
               die inhaltliche Breite der Teildisziplin verkörpern. Sie wählen eine:n Sprecher:in
               und bestimmen in jedem Jahr die Schwerpunktthemen der kommenden Bände, die jeweils
               von einer kleinen Redaktionsgruppe betreut werden. Daneben gibt es Raum für
               themenungebundene Abhandlungen, Diskussionen sowie für die Publikation ausgewählter
               Quellen mit Kommentierung. Seine zunehmende Verbreitung in europäischen
               wissenschaftlichen Bibliotheken und die steigenden Zahl englischsprachiger Beiträge
               sind Ausdruck wachsender Internationalität des Jahrbuchs für Historische
               Bildungsforschung. Alle Einreichungen werden in einem Peer-Review-Verfahren
               begutachtet.</tei:p>
            <tei:p>Die Verbreitung digitaler Angebote und Ressourcen ist in den letzten Jahren in
               den Geisteswissenschaften deutlich angestiegen und auch in der Historischen
               Bildungsforschung spielen Verfahren der Digital Humanities eine immer wichtigere
               Rolle. Das Jahrbuch erscheint daher, ermöglicht durch eine DFG-Förderung in dem
               Projekt <tei:title>
                  <tei:ref target="https://gepris.dfg.de/gepris/projekt/463078084" type="crossref">Transformation des Jahrbuchs für Historische Bildungsforschung (JHB) in ein
                     hybrid – print &amp; online – erscheinendes Open Access Journal</tei:ref>
               </tei:title>, als Open-Access Journal mit erweiterter Funktionalität neben der
               Printausgabe.</tei:p>
            <tei:p rend="breadcrumbfix"/>
         </tei:projectDesc>
      </tei:encodingDesc>
      <tei:profileDesc>
         <tei:langUsage>
            <tei:language ident="en">en</tei:language>
         </tei:langUsage>
         <tei:textClass>
            <tei:keywords xml:lang="de">
               <tei:term>Emotional Community</tei:term>
               <tei:term>Kindergarten</tei:term>
               <tei:term>konservative Reaktion</tei:term>
               <tei:term>geschlechtsspezifische Arbeit</tei:term>
            </tei:keywords>
            <tei:keywords xml:lang="en">
               <tei:term>Emotional Community</tei:term>
               <tei:term>Kindergarten</tei:term>
               <tei:term>Conservative Reaction</tei:term>
               <tei:term>Gendered Labor</tei:term>
            </tei:keywords>
         </tei:textClass>
      </tei:profileDesc>
      <tei:revisionDesc>
         <tei:change who="#docxtei2jtei.xsl" when="2024-10-31T16:36:48">Automatische Transformation
            ins jTEI-Format</tei:change>
      </tei:revisionDesc>
   </tei:teiHeader>
   <tei:text>
      <tei:front>
         <tei:div type="abstract" xml:id="abstract_deu" xml:lang="de">
            <tei:p>Dieser Artikel untersucht die Art und Weise, wie die Ausübung von Liebe und
               Pflege durch Frauen im Kindergarten zwischen 1840 und den 1860er Jahren imaginiert,
               gefördert und reguliert wurde. Der von Friedrich Fröbel gegründete Kindergarten war
               ein Erziehungsraum, der von zwei pädagogischen Idealen geleitet wurde: dem freien
               Spiel und dem „mütterlichen Wesen“ der Kindergärtnerin. Das freie Spiel der Kinder
               stand in Wechselwirkung mit den Fragen, Erzählungen und Liedern der Kindergärtnerin.
               Gemeinsam sollten die Kinder wichtige emotionale, moralische und körperliche
               Fähigkeiten für den Eintritt in die Elementarschule und später in die politische
               Gemeinschaft entwickeln. Die Fähigkeit der Frauen, diese neue emotionale Gemeinschaft
               zu kultivieren, war jedoch subversiv gegenüber den Machtstrukturen, die die Grundlage
               für den politischen Status Quo im deutschsprachigen Europa bildeten.
               Kindergärtnerinnen wurden von Revolutionären und Reformern während der Revolution von
               1848 als Akteurinnen für die Kultivierung einer neuen Gesellschaft gefördert und
               mobilisiert. Für die staatlichen und kirchlichen Autoritäten war der Kindergarten ein
               potenziell gefährlicher Raum und die weibliche Pflege- und Liebesleistung musste
               durch Qualifikationsdokumente überwacht werden, die die Konformität mit emotionalen,
               geschlechtlichen und politischen Normen bekräftigten.</tei:p>
         </tei:div>
         <tei:div type="abstract" xml:id="abstract_eng" xml:lang="en">
            <tei:p>This article examines the ways women’s performance of love and care in the
               kindergarten was imagined, promoted, and policed between 1840 through to the 1860s.
               The kindergarten, founded by Friedrich Fröbel, was an educational space that was led
               by two pedagogical ideals: free play and the female kindergartner’s “maternal
               essence.” Children’s free play interacted with the kindergartner’s questions,
               storytelling, and songs. Together, children were to develop key emotional, moral, and
               physical skills to enter the elementary school and later political community. Women’s
               ability to cultivate this new emotional community however was subversive to the power
               structures that laid the basis for the political status quo in German-speaking
               Europe. Female kindergartners were promoted as agents to help cultivate a new society
               and mobilized as such by revolutionaries and reformers during the 1848 revolution.
               For state and religious authorities, the kindergarten was a potentially dangerous
               space and women’s performance of care and love had to be supervised through
               qualification documents that reiterated conformity to emotional, gendered, and
               political norms.</tei:p>
         </tei:div>
      </tei:front>
      <tei:body>
         <tei:pb n="75"/>
         <tei:div xml:id="div-d1e118">
            <tei:head>1 Introduction</tei:head>
            <tei:p n="1">In 1849, the Hamburg pedagogue and educator Doris Lütkens published reports
               compiled by the kindergartner Alwine Middendorff in her magazine dedicated to
               motherhood and early children’s education, <tei:title level="a">Unsere Kinder oder
                  Literarischer Sprech-Saal für Eltern, Lehrer, Lehrerinnen und Vorsteher von
                  Kleinkinder- und Warteschulen jeder Art.</tei:title>
               <tei:note> See <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid000" target="#Middendorf1849">Middendorff in Lütkens 1849, pp. 163-179</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Middendorff
               (the great-niece of the founder of the kindergarten, Friedrich Fröbel) provided a
               detailed account of the children under her supervision. She described their
               characteristics and development over individual months. Doris Lütkens hoped that
               readers of the “Kindergarten-Chronicle”, and particularly mothers, would be able to
               see the benefits of the Fröbel system. Lütkens maintained throughout the magazine and
               her educational career that the kindergartner and mother were united in the same
               profession: the social, spiritual, and physical cultivation of young children through
               love and care.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid002" target="#Lütkens1849">Lüktens 1849, p. 162</tei:ref>. </tei:note> For Lütkens, the two professions
               were based on maternal love that women supposedly had a natural inclination
                     towards.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid004" target="#Lütkens1849">Ibid., p. 2</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Her magazine was set up to be a space for
               women to share their experiences, learn from teachers, and perfect their craft. As
               she wrote, <tei:quote source="#refid006">Mothers, take
                     heed!</tei:quote><tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid006" target="#Lütkens1849">Ibid., p. 1</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="2">This article focuses on women’s work in the kindergarten from the 1840s through
               the 1860s to examine the ways emotional labor and educational communities were formed
               and disciplined. According to the pedagogues behind the kindergarten, the
               kindergartner helped shape and cultivate an emotional community dedicated to
               children’s social, emotional, and physical development with wider implications that
               moved beyond the classroom and nursery. Friedrich Fröbel trained these female
               educators to challenge children’s supposedly <tei:quote source="#refid008">egotistical</tei:quote> instincts with the use of specially designed toys,
               games, and songs that encouraged the development of emotional skills and knowledge.
               Fröbel’s main activities for these young children included play with balls and
               blocks, songs, and storytelling that triggered reflective questions and
               understandings of the self.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid008" target="#Lange1874">Lange 1874, p. 583</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid009" target="#Wasmuth2020">Wasmuth 2020, p. 77</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> Young children supposedly would be able to understand themselves as an
               individual and yet also part of a larger community that came with responsibility to
               support one another. With their interaction with the kindergartner, children were
               encouraged to think about how others felt and to recognize the emotions of happiness,
               sadness, and disappointment. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="3">For Fröbel and his kindergartners, empathy was a major learning goal. This
               emotion not only established belonging and responsibilities, but also supposedly
               encouraged ethical and moral reasoning. Empathy therefore was not simply a feeling
               that reflected on the individual, but also one that promoted an active
                  response.<tei:note> See <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid012" target="#Frevert2014">Eitler in Frevert 2014, pp. 94-114</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
               Through this, children would supposedly be able to not only develop an active play
               community in the kindergarten but also enter society with necessary emotional skills. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="4">Empathy is a political, ethical, and social emotion. On one level the
               kindergarten cultivated children’s empathetic skills to be part of a larger
               community. On the other, the kindergarten also participated in mobilizing both
               empathetic feelings for middle class women to follow their supposed biological
               maternal destinies and shame for those women who could not fulfil this role.</tei:p>
            <tei:p n="5">Middendorff’s report displayed the kindergarten system at work with a particular
               emphasis on demonstrating the emotional skills and cues that children developed. Two
               children stand out to the reader in the first few pages: the siblings Joseph and
               Kätchen (aged 6 and 5).<tei:note> See <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid014" target="#Middendorf1849">Middendorff in Lütkens 1849, p. 163</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> Joseph was a curious and attentive child who enjoyed hearing stories. He
               responded to the performative storytelling and the bright display of excitement and
               curiosity that Middendorff utilized in her kindergarten. His sister Kätchen, by
               comparison, was very stubborn and required constant discipline. Middendorff wrote
               that <tei:quote source="#refid016">Kätchen has a weak, cautious, and receptive
                  disposition,</tei:quote> and that she did not want to join the group of children.
               Yet after some time, Kätchen became more involved. <tei:quote source="#refid016">Now
                  every day brings more pleasure and love,</tei:quote> Middendorf continued:
                  <tei:quote source="#refid016">Even if a serious word must be spoken from time to
                  time, a look, a hint, is often enough to bring her back to the
                     point.</tei:quote><tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid016" target="#Middendorf1849">Ibid</tei:ref>.</tei:note> Middendorff highlighted the
               ways the emotions of care and love were utilized as a pedagogical and disciplinary
               tool. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="6">In a moving episode, Kätchen responded to the tone and expression used by the
               kindergartner. As Middendorff reported, </tei:p>
            <tei:quote source="#refid018"><tei:pb n="76"/>One of Kätchen’s moves was truly touching
               to me. All the children were catching the ball, and Kätchen's ball fell. Rosa wanted
               to pick it up for her, but Kätchen thought she wanted to take it away from her. She
               tore it violently from Rosa's hands and scratched her. She bled and showed me her
               hand with a piteous face. I called Kätchen to me and asked her whether this was right
               and proper. There must have been something sad in my tone and expression [because]
               Kätchen was quite shaken. She turned red all over and dared not open her eyes.
               Suddenly, she fell on my neck, crying and exclaiming: ‘Please, Alwine, I won’t do it
                     again.’<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid018" target="#Middendorf1849">Ibid., p. 164</tei:ref>.</tei:note>
            </tei:quote>
            <tei:p n="7">Middendorff highlighted the vibrant emotions in this encounter between herself
               and Kätchen. The young girl did not reflect on her interaction with Rosa until faced
               by the vocal tone and facial expressions of the kindergartner. The encounter
               encourages the reader to think of the ways that shaming, even if unintentional, was
               required in learning empathy. As Middendorff stated, this brought Kätchen in line
               with the kindergarten play community. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="8">Middendorff’s report is a valuable case not only to examine how the performance
               of care and love could be used as vital pedagogical tools but also how kindergartners
               were supposed to relate to the children. As she stated, <tei:quote source="#refid020">If we wish to deal with children, we must be children ourselves
                  and yet must stand far above children.</tei:quote><tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid020" target="#Middendorf1849">Ibid., p. 165</tei:ref>.´</tei:note>
               Her report demonstrated how exaggerating certain emotions – sadness, disappointment,
               and excitement – help children become emotionally aware. This emotional awareness,
               according to Middendorff and the early promoters of the kindergarten, was a key
               component of knowledge creation and belonging. At the same time, these were
               pedagogical techniques. The kindergartner, according to Middendorff, needed to guide
               and observe yet also identify with the child. All of this was an act of love, she
               concluded. She envisioned this love as social, attentive, and maternal. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="9">By the late 1840s, the kindergarten and women’s role in it were undoubtedly
               attached to the revolutionary hopes for a new future envisioned by political and
               religious dissenters who protested and built barricades across major cities of
               German-speaking Europe.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid022" target="#Münchow2006">Münchow 2006</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid023" target="#Paletschek1990">Paletschek 1990</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid024" target="#Kleinau1997">Kleinau 1997</tei:ref>;
                     <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid025" target="#Baader1998">Baader
                     1998</tei:ref> and <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid026" target="#Baader1999">1999</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid027" target="#Allen2017">Allen 2017</tei:ref>. </tei:note> The kindergarten, by Fröbel’s thinking, was
               a contagious space. It was explicitly designed to help with the organization and
               function of the family and, eventually, of civil society. During the 1848 Revolution,
               journalist Rudolf Benfey wrote to the Göttingen-based publisher Joseph Stargardt
               about the potential of the kindergarten in Bad Liebenstein, particularly emphasizing
               Alwine Middendorff’s work in promoting a new democratic world.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid034" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">GStA PK, I HA Rep
                     77 Ministerium des Innern Tit 421 Nr. 28, Die Anlegung eines „Kindergartens”
                     nach Fröbelschen Gründsätzen seitens des Dr. Storch in Nordhausen. März 1851
                     bis 26 Mai 1899</tei:ref>. </tei:note> For Gotha-based writer Ludwig Storch,
                  the<tei:pb n="77"/> kindergarten was a space led by women for the work of
                     democracy.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid036" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Kindergartner Amalie Krüger
               also reiterated the view that the institution was a space of utopian hope for the
               future in her letters to Friedrich Fröbel.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid038" target="#König1990">Krüger/König 1990, p.
                  57</tei:ref>.</tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="10">State officials in Prussia and Saxony recognized the radical and destabilizing
               potential of the kindergarten and women’s work. In his report, Berlin Police
               President Karl Ludwig Friedrich von Hinckeldey labeled the kindergarten a <tei:quote source="#refid040">nursery of destruction</tei:quote> that was set on converting
               children to atheism and socialism. It was subsequently banned in both states in
               August 1851.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid040" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">GStA PK, I HA Rep 77 Ministerium des Innern Tit 421 Nr. 28, Hinckeldey an den
                     Königlichen gemeinen Staats- und Minister des Innern Ritter Herrn von
                     Westphalen, p. 11; Ibid., an Seine Majestät den König, p.
                  4R</tei:ref>.</tei:note> By 1860, the Prussian Minister of Education and Culture
               Moritz August von Bethmann-Hollweg demanded that to lift the kindergarten ban, potential
               kindergartners would be required to prove their social, political, moral, and
               religious qualifications.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid042" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">GStA PK, I. HA Rep 77. Tit 421. Nr. 28, Bethmann
                     Hollweg an den Königlichen Staats und Minister des Innern, Herrn Grafen von
                     Schwerin, p. 62</tei:ref>.</tei:note> These requirements reiterated the need
               for women to conform to gender and emotional norms and to the political status
               quo.</tei:p>
            <tei:p n="11">Scholars of emotions have developed theoretical concepts such as <tei:quote source="#refid044">emotional regimes,</tei:quote> <tei:quote source="#refid044">emotional practices,</tei:quote> and <tei:quote source="#refid044">affective
                  economies</tei:quote> to examine the fluidity of power and disciplinary
                  mechanisms.<tei:note> See <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid044" target="#Rosenwein2002">Rosenwein 2002</tei:ref>, <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid045" target="#Rosenwein2006">2006</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid046" target="#Reddy2001">Reddy 2001</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid047" target="#Ahmed2014">Ahmed 2014</tei:ref>;
                     <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid048" target="#Scheer2012">Scheer
                     2012</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Historian William Reddy defined <tei:quote source="#refid054">emotional regimes</tei:quote> as the foundation for every
               political regime. These are the emotional norms and rules of politics, power, and
               social structure.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid054" target="#Reddy2001">Reddy 2001, p. 129</tei:ref>.</tei:note> Historian Monique Scheer identifies
                  <tei:quote source="#refid056">emotional practice</tei:quote> as performances and
                  <tei:quote source="#refid056">acts of doing</tei:quote> that are situated within
               networks of cultural patterns and knowledge.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid056" target="#Scheer2012">Scheer 2012, p.
                  205</tei:ref>.</tei:note> For Scheer, individuals are not simply “reacting” to
               emotions rather, emotions are tied to other practices that manipulate or activate the
               body. Sara Ahmed has elaborated on the ways emotions and feelings are situated,
               communicated, and shared to form <tei:quote source="#refid058">affective
                  economies.</tei:quote><tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid058" target="#Ahmed2014">Ahmed 2014, pp. 44-49</tei:ref>.</tei:note> This article
               identifies the kindergarten as a learning community that redefined certain emotional
               practices in ways that subverted traditionally defined roles and hierarchal power.
               The nineteenth-century kindergarten emphasized the pedagogy of love and care and
               explicitly required the finetuning of emotional practice and performance. This
               educational model took women’s emotional labor out of the traditional hierarchy of
               power seen in the family household. Additionally, this practice was a vital component
               in constructing a new “affective economy” where children and teachers created new
               learning scripts as well as a new community.</tei:p>
            <tei:p n="12"><tei:pb n="78"/>This article also builds on a larger historiographical trend on
               the kindergarten. Historians have elaborated on the different political goals of the
               kindergarten. Notably, studies have illuminated how the early children’s educational
               institution was mobilized as a vital tool to engage in larger social protest that
               took place during the revolutionary 1840s.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid060" target="#Münchow2006">Münchow 2006</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid061" target="#Paletschek1990">Paletschek
                     1990</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid062" target="#Kleinau1997">Kleinau 1997</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid063" target="#Baader1998">Baader 1998</tei:ref> and <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid064" target="#Baader1999">1999</tei:ref>.</tei:note> Additionally,
               historians of education have also demonstrated how the kindergarten allowed women to
               carve out roles in a male-dominated field that required them to play with and subvert
               ideas of femininity and motherhood. Historian Ann Taylor Allen has led the field in
               exploring the important role of the kindergarten in the German women’s
                     movement.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid070" target="#Allen1991">Allen 1991</tei:ref> and <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid071" target="#Allen2017">2017</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Allen demonstrates how
               motherhood could be both constraining and subverted in ways that empowered women
               activists. The kindergarten, Allen has shown, was a key space for activists to
               demonstrate the importance of women’s work outside of the family home. Additionally,
               Allen has demonstrated how these activists created new forms of knowledge that also
               challenged the constraints placed on women’s economic, professional, and educational
               opportunities.</tei:p>
            <tei:p n="13">I argue that the kindergarten, as an educational space led by women’s work, was a
               site that sought to cultivate children as emotional, political, and social agents in
               the hopes of either stabilizing or promoting a new future. First, I track the ways
               women were constructed as gendered-emotional agents tied to a larger system of power
               and order. Women were imagined as mothers, naturally equipped with love, who would
               help nurture an ideal community. Though some pedagogues envisioned the kindergarten
               solely as part of women’s domestic work, others moved beyond the household and sought
               to mobilize female kindergartners as vital social and political agents. Second, I
               examine how women’s performance of care and gendered labor was policed. Women had to
               submit materials to state authorities in which they testified that they were
               “child-like,” subservient to masculine authority, and lacked a political identity.
               All together, these regulations sought to ensure emotional subservience that would
               not threaten the political status quo. To support this argument, I use a wide source
               base that includes Fröbel’s early letters to promote the kindergarten and the
               writings of two prominent female educators, as well as newspaper articles and police
               reports.</tei:p>
         </tei:div>
         <tei:div xml:id="div-d1e713">
            <tei:head>2 The Construction of the Kindergartner </tei:head>
            <tei:p n="14">Women’s labor was intrinsic to the functioning and success of the kindergarten.
               For Friedrich Fröbel, it was only by encouraging women to join his project, not only
               as educators but also as major financial contributors, that the institution was to
               succeed in June 1840. The construction and promotion of women’s labor<tei:pb n="79"/>
               was a double-edged sword. Fröbel appealed to women’s emotional-pedagogical attributes
               that they supposedly embodied and performed in the family. His understanding of
               women’s nature is inseparable from early nineteenth century ideas of the family that
               defined mothers as key early educators that provided feminine love and encouragement.
               However, this view on women was proscriptive rather than descriptive. Fröbel pointed
               to supposed widespread flaws in women who neglected their duties and sought to
               discipline and <tei:quote source="#refid074">educate</tei:quote>
                     mothers.<tei:note><tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid074" target="#jhb30_04_ff">Entwurf eines Planes zur Begründung und Ausführung eines Kinder-Gartens, einer
                     Allgemeinen Anstalt zur Verbreitung allseitiger Beachtung des Lebens der
                     Kinder, besonders durch Pflege ihres Thätigkeitstriebes</tei:ref>, in:
                  DIPF/BBF/Archiv: Nachlass Fröbel 213, pp. 5-8; Verein zur Ausführung eines
                  Erziehungswerkes durch deutsche Frauen und Jungfrauen, in: DIPF/BBF/Archiv:
                  Nachlass Fröbel Fröbel 214, p. 32. </tei:note></tei:p>
            <tei:p n="15">Fröbel’s approach to women and children was tied to his early educational
               experiences of his own childhood. He was born in the small Thuringian village of
               Oberweißbach on April 21, 1782. His father was a Lutheran pastor who was dedicated to
               the religious upkeep of his community. His work, the younger Fröbel wrote, was
               all-consuming. As a result, Fröbel never developed a close relationship with his
                  father.<tei:note> Fröbel 1889, p. 3. </tei:note> His mother died nine months after
               his birth. Fröbel’s stepmother, soon after having her own children, banished him from
               the family community.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid078" target="#Allen2017">Allen 2017, p.
                     24</tei:ref>. </tei:note> For Fröbel, this early childhood experience of loss,
               the lack of both parental – importantly, maternal – love and freedom shaped how he
               understood education. As he wrote in a letter addressed to women in 1831 (hoping to
               gain potential supporters for his educational projects): </tei:p>
            <tei:quote source="#refid080">with the death, with the loss of my mother, with the loss
               of reciprocal human love between mother and child, from this moment my entire future
               life took on its character and calling… Here I will say only that the soul strives to
               reconstruct that original unity of mind and soul that original experience of community.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid080" target="#Allen2017">Fröbel quoted in Allen
                     2017, p. 24</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:quote>
            <tei:p n="16">In this letter to women in 1831, he continued to describe how his experience at a
               girls’ school, where he received his basic education, deeply impressed him.<tei:note>
                  Fröbel 1889, p. 17. </tei:note> Though he described that he felt foreign in the
               class, he wrote that he <tei:quote source="#refid084">encountered, as it were, the
                  whole feminine, emotional, and religious side of humankind.</tei:quote> He stated
               how he received and witnessed the supposed feminine love that he lacked, <tei:quote source="#refid084">I saw here, as it were, the mind and life of my mother, which I
                  had sought silently but not consciously, but which was also distant and foreign to
                  me, multiplied, as it were, sprouting anew before me.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  Fröbel an die Frauen in Keilhau 1831, in <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid084" target="#Heiland2008">Heiland 2008</tei:ref>; see also <tei:ref target="https://editionen.bbf.dipf.de/exist/apps/briefedition-friedrich-froebel/briefe/fb1831-08-18-03.xml%23JB5">
                     https://editionen.bbf.dipf.de/exist/apps/briefedition-friedrich-froebel/briefe/fb1831-08-18-03.xml#JB5
                  </tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="17"><tei:pb n="80"/>The letter illuminated the supposed different educational and
               emotional capabilities of men and women within the family that had evolved during the
               late eighteenth century from its conception as an economic unit to an idealized
               pedagogical and moral entity.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid086" target="#Frevert1997">Frevert 1997, p.
                     13</tei:ref>. </tei:note> The ideal of the family was redefined during this era
               as one of love, relaxation, and refuge from the daily worries of work and politics.
               Within this conception of the family home, husbands and wives ensured that they
               passed on respectable moral sentiments to their children so that they could reproduce
               the middle-class social ideal. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="18">The workload in the family, however, was not even. Women oversaw that the home
               functioned as a site of refuge and care through their ability to provide emotional support.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid088" target="#Frevert1997">Ibid., p.
                     17</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid089" target="#Habermas2000">Habermas 2000, pp. 62-73</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid090" target="#Baader1996">Baader 1996, pp. 19-24</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Many writers
               thought these sentiments were different from the forms of love and care men could
                  provide.<tei:note> Reill 2005, pp. 220-236. </tei:note> This is not to say that
               men did not have an important role in the function and organization of emotional work
               in the family. Fathers were expected to play an important authority role and to
               provide masculine assurance to young men and boys.<tei:note> Wall 2007; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid097" target="#Rousseau1979">Rousseau
                     1762/1979</tei:ref>. </tei:note> They provided their children with an example
               of how men should be and act. The new role fashioned for women, however, unleashed
               the production of a new genre of educational material that emphasized women’s
               maternal, loving, and subservient role in the family household.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid100" target="#Frevert1997">Frevert 1997, p.
                     17</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="19">For Fröbel, the kindergarten was to be a special space to help assist with the
               functioning of the family. Though, in reworking and focusing on women’s particular
               emotional labor, Fröbel did subvert the traditional hierarchy of authority. Fröbel
               empowered women to join his project and encouraged them to redeem their role as
               caregivers of humanity. He made this clear in his call for noble women to join his
               project in December 1839, where he stressed that he was more and more convinced of
               the importance of early children’s education as a vital element in individual formation.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid102" target="#Hanschmann1874">Hanschmann 1874,
                     p. 306</tei:ref>. </tei:note> It was for this reason, he stated, that this work
               could not be done by men alone. He continued, <tei:quote source="#refid104">the
                  feminine maternal sense of women, feminine maternal love, must be at his side.
                  This love, however, should not be alone, but in common with the masculine striving
                  to grasp the life in the child.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid104" target="#Hanschmann1874">Ibid., p.
                     307</tei:ref>. </tei:note> He claimed, however, that women needed some
               encouragement to join the cause and to reach this realization. It was for this
               reason, he stated, <tei:quote source="#refid106">that a majority of noble,
                  maternally minded German women should unite to form a great whole. A German
                  women’s association for the true and meaningful care of children and
                  childhood.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid106" target="#Hanschmann1874">Ibid., p.
                     307</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="20">This does not mean there was not an element of shaming in this campaign. The
               article, “<tei:title level="a">The Cultivation of Nursemaids</tei:title>,” published
               in the liberal newspaper <tei:title level="s">Allgemeiner Anzeiger und
                  Nationalzeitung der Deutschen</tei:title> encouraged women to join in a national
               cause to help uplift children’s education in a model school and nursery. For the
               anonymous writer of the article, the current state of training available to
               nursemaids was not sufficient. In fact, the writer argued that they did more harm
               than good to the children under their charge. He criticized wealthy mothers for
               choosing non-German women to educate their young children. These young women from
               Switzerland and France supposedly <tei:quote source="#refid108">tormented</tei:quote> and <tei:quote source="#refid108">spoiled</tei:quote>
               young children with <tei:quote source="#refid108">French babbling</tei:quote> and
                  <tei:quote source="#refid108">empty tinkering</tei:quote>.”<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid108" target="#K.H.G.1839">K.H.G. 1839, p.
                     4684</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Instead, young German women should be encouraged to
               train with Fröbel to help prevent a larger stain on humanity and their national
               identity. Joining Fröbel, the author stated, would provide <tei:quote source="#refid110">the best opportunity to learn practically how to treat children
                  and how to occupy themselves with them in the most appropriate way.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid110" target="#K.H.G.1839">Ibid., p.
                     4682</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="21">Fröbel’s method, it was hoped, would provide an example of how to lead children
               and practice maternal love and care that would be extended into family homes. This
               would first and foremost help establish the domestically oriented education women
               needed to successfully care for children.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid112" target="#K.H.G.1839">Ibid., p.
                     4683</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Fröbel opened his first kindergartner training
               seminars in Keilhau and Bad Blankenburg in 1841 before they spread to Hamburg,
               Dresden, and Bad Liebenstein. The seminars were structured to educate women on
               pedagogy, Fröbel’s games and toys for children, and parenting. These students also
               had opportunity to observe the kindergarten.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid114" target="#jhb30_04_ff">Die Kindergärten als
                     um- und erfassende Pflege- und Erziehungsanstalten der Kindheit, der Kinder bis
                     zum schulfähigen Alter und der Deutsche Kindergarten als eine Musteranstalt
                     dafür insbesondere</tei:ref>, in: DIPF/BBF/Archiv: Nachlass Fröbel 29, p. 15.
               </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="22">The kindergarten attracted the support of educators like Doris Lütkens and Bertha
               von Marenholtz-Bülow who also emphasized the necessity of training and developing
               women’s particular emotions to ensure the proper socialization of children. For these
               two educators, women were supposedly endowed with the ability to perform love and
               care that was necessary for the “sentimental” education of young children. In this
               regard, they identified women as key educators for children’s emotional and mental
               well-being that was necessary before they entered elementary schools. Both women were
               far from political radicals but sought to promote an ideal of motherhood and women’s
               education that moved beyond the traditional framework of the family
               household.</tei:p>
            <tei:p n="23"><tei:pb n="81"/>Doris Lütkens joined Fröbel’s training seminar in 1847. Lütkens
               had already established herself as an educator in Hamburg before she met Fröbel at a
               children’s festival in Quetz near Magdeburg in 1847. In 1841, she had opened the
               Teaching and Pension Institute for Higher Daughters in the St. Georg North suburb of
               Hamburg. During her seventeen years as director, the school developed a reputation as
               a space for women’s education for the middle classes that adhered to socially
               acceptable gender ideas. Lütkens remained tied to a class-based ideal of gendered
               education. Though Lütkens had conflicts with other female supporters of the
               kindergarten, notably her kindergartner Alwine Middendorff, who sought to move away
               from strict religious orthodoxy, she promoted the kindergarten and women’s work in
               her magazine in a way that destabilized the traditional status quo. She presented a
               space for women’s education and motherhood that moved away from the structures of
               masculine authority in the household. In her magazine <tei:title level="s">Unsere
                  Kinder</tei:title> she sought to bring women, pedagogues, and teachers together to
               promote educational material and approaches that ensured <tei:quote source="#refid116">free</tei:quote> and <tei:quote source="#refid116">natural</tei:quote> development of young children.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid116" target="#Lütkens1849">Lükens 1849, p.
                     1</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="24">One should not over-emphasize the ways Lütkens formulated the space of the family
               and women’s work. She did remain tied to the position of the family as a central
               space of socialization and heavily identified women as supposedly endowed with loving
               and caring natures. She nonetheless put forth a form of women’s work that was not
               bound to patriarchal discipline and therefore made alternative ideals of society and
               authority possible. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="25">Bertha von Marenholtz-Bülow continued this discursive construction of the
               kindergarten, especially after the kindergarten was banned in 1851. Marenholtz-Bülow
               promoted the institution as an anti-revolutionary, anti-socialist approach to the
               “social question.” For intellectuals of the nineteenth century, the “social question”
               centered on the crises that emerged with the industrial transformation of society.
               For Marenholtz-Bülow, women’s work was a vital component to answer the question. She
               reformulated the kindergarten as an institution increasingly tied to a form of social
               pedagogy aimed at the children of the lower classes. Her work abroad launched a
               transnational and international discussion on women’s supposedly natural role as
               mothers for the care of poor children. Her work was thereby entangled in a European
               and North American wide movement for social order, respectability, and bourgeois
               middle class reform.<tei:note> See <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid118" target="#Allen2017">Allen 2017, p. 45</tei:ref>; <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid119" target="#Morley1855">Morley 1855, p. 577-582</tei:ref>;
                     <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid120" target="#Osterhammel2014">Osterhammel
                     2014, pp. 507-512</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="26">In 1854 Marenholtz-Bülow published an English pamphlet directed to supporters of
               the kindergarten in Britain, in which she highlighted her blend of women’s education
               and social reform. She made it clear that women’s mission as “social mothers” in the
               kindergarten was vital not just for the fundamental early years of<tei:pb n="82"/>
               childhood. It was also central to her belief in a moral crusade to uplift the working
               classes. <tei:quote source="#refid124">The regeneration of education must begin with
                  woman,</tei:quote> she stated, <tei:quote source="#refid124">who has her mission
                  to fulfil in this age, not only as mother in the domestic circle, but also as
                  mother to the poor and helpless orphans of the lower classes, who experience no
                  maternal care from those who gave them birth.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid124" target="#Marenholtz-Bülow1855">Marenholtz-Bülow 1855, p. 78</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Women of the educated
               classes had a moral duty not only to educate themselves for the profession of
               motherhood, but also to care for the children of the poor. Poor mothers, according to
               Marenholtz-Bülow, were unable to provide for their children. As she stated,
                  <tei:quote source="#refid126">until the mothers amongst the lower classes are a
                  better educated race, the education of their children must be under the care of
                  the educated classes.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid126" target="#Marenholtz-Bülow1855">Ibid., p.
                     86</tei:ref>; see also <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid127" target="#Jones1971">Jones 1971</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="27">Marenholtz-Bülow elaborated on a system of education and training that sought to
               mobilize women’s particular emotional capabilities for the sake of social uplift. For
               her, middle-class women were needed to carry on the work of the kindergarten as a way
               to emphasis women’s domestic and maternal identity. Marenholtz-Bülow proposed that
               women’s education, in her words, <tei:quote source="#refid130">should unquestionably
                  offer the means of cultivating the faculties of the female sex with a special view
                  to their future vocation.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid130" target="#Marenholtz-Bülow1855">Marenholtz-Bülow 1855, p. 81</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="28">Fröbel, Lütkens, and Marenholtz-Bülow, helped to define the kindergarten as a
               unique space to construct and promote women’s labor that remained tied to their
               supposed emotional natures. They emphasized women’s ability to perform an empathetic
               love and care that encouraged emotional reactions and introspection from both
               children and other mothers. Indeed, women were encouraged by these writers to feel
               that it was their mission to get involved in the kindergarten project. If women chose
               not to, these writers employed shaming techniques that also targeted their supposed
               gender roles. However, even within these formulations we see the potential for
               subversion. Women were encouraged to perform and practice an active motherhood that
               was not necessarily tied to the home. </tei:p>
         </tei:div>
         <tei:div xml:id="div-d1e1294">
            <tei:head>3 Policing and Disciplining Women’s Labor in the Kindergarten </tei:head>
            <tei:p n="29">Many women that joined the profession during the revolutionary 1840s and early
               1850s largely saw the kindergarten as a space to use their supposed “natural essence”
               for social, cultural, and political change. The discursive construction of the
               kindergartner provided room for subversion and play. Without the presence of
               representatives of traditional masculine authority, maternal love and care was
               re-imagined by some kindergartners, political and religious dissenters, and
               pedagogues as a revolutionary force that could challenge the status quo. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="30"><tei:pb n="83"/>Prussian and Saxon state authorities recognized the revolutionary
               aspects of the kindergarten and banned the early children’s institution in August
               1851. The kindergarten ban was one example of the ways German states purged the
               educational environment of radical elements that authorities saw as threatening. The
               Prussian state, in particular, also introduced other methods to rid civil society of
               future potential revolutionary upheaval and to stabilize emotional norms that
               included new teaching regulations, a new emphasis on the relationship between the
               church and the state, and curricula for students that emphasized loyalty to country
               and monarchy.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid132" target="#Stiehl1858">Stiehl 1858</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="31">In response to petitions to lift the ban in 1859, the Prussian state turned to
               policing women’s labor to ensure that the kindergarten was not used for revolutionary
               ends. Minister of Education and Culture Moritz August von Bethmann-Hollweg suggested
               that the method of granting state concessions be used to discipline and safeguard the
               kindergarten. Concessions were vital as a form of quality control. First introduced
               on December 31, 1834, concessions allowed the state to police independent private schools.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid134" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">GStA PK, I. HA
                     Rep77. Tit 421. Nr. 28, 61</tei:ref>. </tei:note> State officials would go
               through concession documents and inspect proposed institutions to ensure that they
               met state requirements.</tei:p>
            <tei:p n="32">Women who desired to become kindergartners, Bethmann-Hollweg wrote, had to submit
                  <tei:quote source="#refid136">proof of the necessary religious, moral and
                  political qualifications.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid136" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> This material ensured, he continued, the <tei:quote source="#refid138">sufficient means to keep unqualified or morally and politically unsuitable
                  persons away from employment in Fröbelian kindergartens.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid138" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> The concessions themselves went beyond any form of pedagogical training
               documents. State officials specifically wanted to ensure women were religiously
               minded, maintained good community relations, and stayed out of trouble. In essence,
               concessions would prevent the kindergarten from becoming radicalized. In this way,
               Bethmann-Hollweg unleashed a new system for the professionalizing of kindergartners
               that firmly placed women teachers inside traditional gender norms and expectations. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="33">In what follows we will see how institutions and the state facilitated these new
               expectations and qualifications particularly by focusing on the case of Ida Seele and
               Marie Zürn. These two women were put forth by Berlin Frauenverein für die Beförderung
               der Fröbel’schen Kindergärten (Berlin Women’s Association to Promote the Fröbelian
               Kindergarten). The association sought to open kindergartens in the city on Fröbel’s
               and Bertha von Marenholtz-Bülow’s model. This was a type of kindergarten that was
               tied to the liberal middle-class and shunned any connection to revolutionaries. The
               association presented their documents to the state by emphasizing subservient ideals
               of femininity and mother love and care. However,<tei:pb n="84"/> this promotion of
               the kindergarten also required the kindergartners themselves to play and practice
               this role. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="34">On May 12, 1860, the Berlin Women’s Association sent a package to the Royal
               School Collegium containing their request for a concession to open a kindergarten and
               the qualification documents belonging to Ida Seele. Seele’s documents showed state
               authorities the path she had taken to become a kindergartner. It was a career she had
               always had in mind. She emphasized how her early childhood experience with illness
               and loss, particularly the death of her mother, moved her to look seriously at the
               care and education of children. As a child, Seele spent most of her time under the
               care of nannies and suffered from poor vision as well as poor physical health. She
               attributed her poor vision and health to the supposedly inefficient training of her nannies.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid140" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid., p.
                     6</tei:ref>. </tei:note> During this time, Seele wrote, she developed a
                  <tei:quote source="#refid142">boundless love and devotion for small children,
                  which will guide me through my whole life.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid142" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> <tei:quote source="#refid144">From that point on,</tei:quote> she wrote
               in her <tei:title level="a">Lebenslauf</tei:title>, <tei:quote source="#refid144">the purpose of my life was to keep the little ones cheerful and free of worries,
                  as much as their weak strength could do, and the kindergarten also tries to
                  fulfill this purpose.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid144" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="35">Seele described her experiences at the <tei:emph>Bürgertöchterschule</tei:emph>,
               an educational institute for daughters of the middle and upper class. Here, she had
               found refuge from her brother’s cruel teasing. The school, she wrote, <tei:quote source="#refid146">was soon my favorite place. There I found consolation in
                  religion; there was no regard for the person’s [outer appearance]; there I was
                  taken care of for my spirit.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid146" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> She reported that she had surpassed her classmates in her final year in
               religion, biblical history, reading, spelling, German grammar, natural history, and
               singing. After Seele completed school, her aunt, who had become a primary funder of
               her education, told her teacher, <tei:quote source="#refid148">Ida should not become
                  a scholar, but an efficient housewife and for that she has learned
                  enough.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid148" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid., p.
                     8</tei:ref>. </tei:note> From this moment, Seele stayed home, where she did the
               cooking, washing, and sewing. She did this work with joy and happiness, she wrote,
               while keeping in mind her dream of working with children.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid150" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> By Seele’s own telling, her origins were not those of a radical.</tei:p>
            <tei:p n="36">In 1843, the eighteen-year-old Seele had noticed an article calling for
               kindergartners written by Friedrich Fröbel. While her family did not fully support
               her, her brother funded her trip to Bad Blankenburg where she joined the larger
               community surrounding Friedrich Fröbel’s kindergarten project.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid152" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid., p.
                     10</tei:ref>. </tei:note> She remained under Fröbel’s supervision until August
               1, 1844, spending the first half of the<tei:pb n="85"/> year as his student and the
               rest of the time as the director of his kindergarten in Blankenburg.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid154" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="37">Rather than paint the kindergarten as a revolutionary institution, Seele
               described a loving and pious space for children to learn. For Seele, the Blankenburg
               kindergarten was a site of spiritual life. She wrote, <tei:quote source="#refid156">here I found people whom I looked up to as the highest ideals of human
                  perfection.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid156" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> The community, both young and old, gathered together during the morning
               and evening hours to pray for God’s protection as they welcomed work with good cheer.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid158" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid.,
                     10RS</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Fröbel and his collaborator Wilhelm Middendorff
               were respectable figures who were pious and loved children. Seele noted Fröbel’s
               relationships with nobles as well as with teachers, children, farmers, men and women.
               Seele thereby defined the kindergarten as an idyllic space where all classes came
               together in harmony but not in revolutionary-like equality. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="38">Seele ensured that she distanced herself from known radicals in her <tei:title level="a">Lebenslauf</tei:title>. In fact, she wrote that she had split with
               Fröbel. She had heard about the religious and political issues circling the
               kindergartens particularly in Hamburg, seen by Prussian authorities as the prime
               location of revolutionary radicalism. That revolutionary activity, she stated,
                  <tei:quote source="#refid160">went against my nature.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid160" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid., p.
                     14</tei:ref>. </tei:note> It is hard to know how sincere Seele was in her
               condemnation of the situation in Hamburg. It is clear that she understood her
               audience, since she played up her childlike innocence and religious qualities which
               were supposedly natural for women. She wrote, <tei:quote source="#refid162">I have a
                  childlike spirit that cannot live without religion and I am always and forever a
                  loyal supporter of the princely houses and a good patriot.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid162" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid.,
                     14-14RS</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="39">Seele’s references from former employers pointed to her pedagogical method, her
               moral Aand emotional capabilities, and her religious identity. They similarly
               positioned her as an ideal woman and teacher whose character undermined any charge of
               radicalism or dissent in the kindergarten. In a character review of her time as a
               kindergartner in Bad Blankenburg, the director of the Model School in Frankfurt wrote
               that Seele’s work was said to epitomize the maternal love and care that was necessary
               in the school. She was credited with having converted the letter-writer to the cause
               of the kindergarten. As he wrote in her reference letter: </tei:p>
            <tei:quote source="#refid164">it was mainly Ida Seele who, through her practical
               successes, won me over to the subject of kindergartens and through her wonderful
               devotion to the children, as well as through the amiable naturalness and sensibility
               with which she grasped and carried out her task, touched me as much as it inspired me.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid164" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid., p.
                     19</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:quote>
            <tei:p n="40"><tei:pb n="86"/>Seele’s supposedly religious nature was emphasized throughout her
               documents as a way to highlight her moral qualifications. In another reference
               letter, the director of the Keilhau Educational Institute praised her “childlike
               religious nature” as an essential aspect in her success as an educator. The director
               wrote <tei:quote source="#refid166">that Fröbel has always given his special
                  satisfaction about her because of her childlike religious sense and her sensible
                  and devoted manner in dealing with small children.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid166" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid., p.
                     20</tei:ref>. </tei:note> She was also defined as a <tei:quote source="#refid168">friend of the Church,</tei:quote> and it was noted that she
                  <tei:quote source="#refid168">regularly sought her edification in [religion]. In
                  moral terms she is highly respectable.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid168" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid., p.
                     21</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="41">Her collection of nine references set out to promote an ideal image of the
               kindergartner. In them, Seele distanced herself from the revolutionary activism of
               the 1840s. She had a childlike religious nature that was important for educating
               children. In her documents, Seele presented an image of herself as one that was
               dedicated, womanly, natural, outside of politics, and Christian. Women like Ida
               Seele, who identified by Prussian authorities as politically subservient, were
               granted a concession by the state to work in the kindergarten. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="42">Ida Seele’s experiences with the inspectors of the Royal School Collegium
               differed from those of Marie Zürn. Like Seele, Zürn was a kindergartner trained and
               educated by Friedrich Fröbel. She was recommended to work as an assistant for Seele
               on April 30, 1860. However, by August 7, the Berlin Women’s Association had
               terminated her employment. At this same time, Marie Zürn sent a formal request for
               permission to teach at a kindergarten in Potsdam to the School Deputation. The
               subsequent investigation into her request for a concession to work in the
               kindergarten demonstrated how the state’s moral and class considerations shaped the
               kindergartner profession. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="43">Marie Zürn had completed six months of training as a kindergartner under
               Friedrich Fröbel in 1850 in Bad Liebenstein. She later traveled to Göttingen and
               worked in a kindergarten there for ten months. Although individuals such as Ida Seele
               had the benefit of a good relationship with their employers, Zürn had had many issues
               with male pedagogues and <tei:quote source="#refid170">cold and stern</tei:quote>
               women patrons.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid170" target="#König1990">Zürn/König 1990, p.
                     215</tei:ref>. </tei:note> She wrote to Fröbel on March 31, 1851, asking for
               advice on her current work environment in Göttingen. She reported that because of one
               of the directors of the institute, a man only known as Cantor Dietrich, she had to
               shorten her stay in the kindergarten. As she wrote, <tei:quote source="#refid172">among six of my colleagues, five would not have endured so long after such
                  humiliating treatment. I did so out of love for the children and because I
                  believed that things would turn out differently.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid172" target="#König1990">Ibid. p. 244</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> Even her former allies, Zürn found, would rather support the male
               pedagogue who had connections in the city than heed her complaints of meanness and
               cruelty: <tei:quote source="#refid174">even<tei:pb n="87"/> Ms. Levin, who had acted
                  maternally toward me from the beginning, said that if I admitted this [her
                  conflict with Dietrich], she would be completely disappointed in me. C. is much
                  too well known.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid174" target="#König1990">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="44">Zürn was afraid, after calling out Dietrich’s abuse of power over these women.
               She wrote to Fröbel that, <tei:quote source="#refid176">he threatened me at that
                  time, that if I did not remain good-willed, he would know how to implicate me with
                  you [Fröbel] in such a way that I would never get another job.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid176" target="#König1990">Ibid., p.
                  245</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Dietrich also continued to threaten her and Fröbel
               because of their allegiance to the dissenting congregation.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid178" target="#König1990">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> This confrontation illuminates an under-researched reality in these
               educational institutions: women were under the sway and mercy of the male directors
               and pedagogues. Zürn relocated to another position in Breslau where she worked as a
               French teacher in a private educational institute with connections to the dissenting
               German-Catholic Congregation. She then traveled back to her hometown of Rudolstadt
               and established a kindergarten there in 1858. She later traveled to Arnstadt in 1859
               as a private school teacher.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid180" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">GStA PK, I. HA Rep
                     77. Tit 421. Nr. 28, p. 79</tei:ref>. </tei:note>
            </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="45">Despite the impressions created by the problems in Göttingen, Zürn was an
               experienced kindergartner with Fröbelian credentials. At first glance, it seemed that
               Zürn, like Seele, should easily have met the Prussian state’s criteria. But the state
               had concerns. An official at the School Collegium reported in August 1861, that while
                  <tei:quote source="#refid182">teaching gave her life value,</tei:quote> there
               was something that was morally questionable in her lifestyle.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid182" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid</tei:ref>.
               </tei:note> The official wrote that the issue was poverty: such <tei:quote source="#refid184">completely penniless girls</tei:quote> did not have financial
               stability through teaching.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid184" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">Ibid., p.
                     80</tei:ref>. </tei:note> On September 30, 1861, another report compiled by
               officials working at the Interior Ministry was sent to Interior Minister Maximillian
               von Schwerin-Putzar stating that the <tei:quote source="#refid186">unmarried Marie
                  Zürn</tei:quote> was not only rejected but also expelled from the city due to
                  <tei:quote source="#refid186">certain information</tei:quote> collected by the
               Prussian police officers that defined her as a <tei:quote source="#refid186">highly
                  immoral person.</tei:quote><tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid186" target="#jhb30_04_gsta">GStA PK, I. HA Rep
                     77. Tit 421. Nr. 28, p. 83RS</tei:ref>. </tei:note> It was not just Zürn’s
               poverty that concerned the Prussian state; it was also allegations of sexual
               impropriety. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="46">The Zürn and Seele documents illuminate the form of policing, disciplining, and
               performance that went into defining the kindergartner profession. The documents
               provided an outlet for women to define and stake out their positions, however they
               had to remain aligned to the qualification terms presented by the Prussian state that
               sought conformity to a form of femininity and emotional labor that would not threaten
               the state. In these two cases, women’s labor was also firmly established within a
               hierarchy of power and authority. </tei:p>
         </tei:div>
         <tei:div xml:id="div-d1e1946">
            <tei:head>4 Conclusion</tei:head>
            <tei:p n="47"><tei:pb n="88"/>Though not all kindergartens were utilized for political ends,
               they were constructed as an alternative emotional-pedagogical space that sought to
               support both the family and classroom in ways that side-stepped the traditional
               patriarchal authority that shaped both these sites. It was exactly this idea of love
               and care, unchecked by traditional forces of authority, that could threaten the
               political and social status quo. It was not only state and religious authorities who
               were anxious about a space that empowered women. It was also other male and female
               pedagogues who saw that if women’s education and professional training was unchecked,
               it could lead to social and cultural collapse. Some pedagogues, notably the famed
               liberal reformer Adolph Diesterweg, claimed that too much education can make women ugly.<tei:note>
                  <tei:ref type="bibl" xml:id="refid188" target="#Diesterweg1851">Diesterweg, 1851,
                     p. 151</tei:ref>. </tei:note> Fröbel himself also saw this profession as
               “temporary”. The state then sought to check and discipline women’s positions in the
               kindergarten, fearing that their performance and practice of care could unleash a
               dangerous future. Women had to perform proper femininity through new qualification
               materials that ensured the kindergarten would not spread chaos beyond the nursery. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="48">This examination allows us to see a different window into the history of the
               politics of the classroom and particularly focus on the question of who and how
               emotions were used in pedagogy and how these terms were deployed. The performance of
               emotions, such as love, can inoculate patriotism, loyalty, and subservience. But it
               can also promote new ideas of freedom, political protest, and radical possibilities
               for a new democratic future. </tei:p>
            <tei:p n="49">Learning and experiencing empathy was part of this educational project.
               Pedagogues, educators, and social reformers sought to encourage empathetic feelings
               within children to develop a form of belonging as well as a sense of responsibility
               to their communities. Empathy however also had with it an important aspect of
               shaming. Children were shamed as a pedagogical tool to realize that they had done
               something socially unacceptable. Women were also shamed if they could not perform
               proper maternal love and care. </tei:p>
         </tei:div>
      </tei:body>
      <tei:back>
         <tei:div xml:id="div-bibl" type="bibliography">
            <tei:head>Literature and Sources</tei:head>
            <tei:desc>Bibliographie online verfügbar auf
               <tei:ptr target="https://www.zotero.org/groups/4596542/collections/SJ4EWFMC"/>.
            </tei:desc>
            <tei:ref target="https://www.zotero.org/groups/4596542/collections/SJ4EWFMC"/>
            <tei:listBibl type="nonpublishedsources">
               <tei:head>Unpublished Sources</tei:head>
               <tei:listBibl>
                  <tei:head>Archiv der Bibliothek für Bildungsgeschichtliche Forschung, Berlin
                     (DIPF/BBF/Archiv)</tei:head>
                  <tei:bibl xml:id="jhb30_04_ff">Friedrich Fröbel Nachlass. </tei:bibl>
               </tei:listBibl>
               <tei:listBibl>
                  <tei:head>Geheimes Staatsarchiv Preußischer Kulturbesitz Berlin-Dahlem (GStA
                     PK)</tei:head>
                  <tei:bibl xml:id="jhb30_04_gsta">I HA Rep 77 Ministerium des Innern Tit 421 Nr.
                     28, Die Anlegung eines “Kindergartens” nach Fröbelschen Gründsätzen seitens des
                     Dr. Storch in Nordhausen. - März 1851 bis 26 Mai 1899.</tei:bibl>
               </tei:listBibl>
               <tei:listBibl>
                  <tei:head>Landesarchiv Berlin (LAB)</tei:head>
                  <tei:bibl xml:id="jhb30_04_lab9817">A Pr. Br. Rep. 030 tit. 94 Nr. 9817, Acta der
                     Königlichen Polizei-Prasidii zu Berlin an Friedrich Fröbel
                     1852/1858.</tei:bibl>
                  <tei:bibl xml:id="jhb30_04_lab784">A. Rep. 020-02 Nr 784 Magistrate der Stadt
                     Berlin, Städtische Schuldeputation, Die Kindergärten des Frauenvereines zur
                     Beförderung der Kindergärten.</tei:bibl>
               </tei:listBibl>
            </tei:listBibl>
            <tei:listBibl type="publishedsources">
               <tei:head>Published Sources</tei:head>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Delius1891" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/XFAGIEHL">Delius, Hans (1891): Das
                  preußische Vereins- und Versammlungsrecht unter besonderer Berücksichtigung des
                  Gesetzes vom 11. März 1850. Berlin.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Diesterweg1851" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/RFLL3G2S">Diesterweg, Adolph
                  (1851): Rheinische Blätter für Erziehung und Unterricht mit besonderer
                  Berücksichtigung des Volksschulwesens. 25 Jahrgang. Essen. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Hanschmann1874" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/V4CW3TJB">Hanschmann, Alexander
                  Bruno (1874): Friedrich Fröbel: Die Entwickelung seiner Erziehungsidee in seinem
                  Leben. Eisenach.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="K.H.G.1839" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/IYTWY2RF">K.H.G. (December 31,
                  1839): “Die Bildung der Kindermädchen”. In: Allgemeiner Anzeiger und
                  Nationalzeitung der Deutschen, Nr. 355, 4684.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Lange1874" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/B9LTAJ7T">Lange, Wichard (1874):
                  Pädagogik des Kindergartens, Second Edition, Berlin. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Lütkens1849" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/2J2IRUFB">Lütkens, Doris (1849):
                  Unsere Kinder oder Literarischer Sprech-Saal für Eltern, Lehrer, Lehrerinnen und
                  Vorsteher von Kleinkinder- und Warteschulen jeder Art. Hamburg. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Lyschinska1922" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/NTHL2MEY">Lyschinska, Mary (1922):
                  Henriette Schrader-Breymann: ihr Leben aus Briefen und Tagebüchern.
                  Berlin.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Marenholtz-Bülow1855" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/LZZD4FT3">Marenholtz-Bülow, Bertha
                  von (1855): Women’s Educational Mission. London: Darton &amp; Co.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Middendorf1849" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/E6ZCLVKE">Middendorff, Alwine
                  (1849): "Kindergarten-Chronik." In: Unsere Kinder oder Literarischer Sprech-Saal
                  für Eltern, Lehrer, Lehrerinnen und Vorsteher von Kleinkinder-und Warteschulen
                  jeder Art. Hamburg, pp. 163-179.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Morley1855" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/QMINXSLY">Morley, Henry (July 21,
                  1855): “Infant Gardens” in Household Words. A Weekly Journal, Nr. 278, pp.
                  577-582.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Stiehl1858" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/YN5ZBU66">Stiehl, A.W. Friedrich
                  (1858): Die drei Preußischen Regulative von 1, 2, und 3, October 1854 über
                  Einrichtung des evangelischen Seminar-, Präparanden- und Seminarschul Unterrichts.
                  Berlin.</tei:bibl>
            </tei:listBibl>
            <tei:listBibl type="literature">
               <tei:head>Literature</tei:head>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Ahmed2014" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/MFM76CYF">Ahmed, Sara (2014): The
                  Cultural Politics of Emotion, Second Edition. Edinburgh, <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203700372">https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203700372</tei:ref>.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Albisetti1989" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/2IF3SDT4">Albisetti, James C.
                  (1989): Schooling German Girls and Women: Secondary and Higher Education in the
                  Nineteenth Century.<tei:emph> </tei:emph>Princeton,
                  <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400859795">https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400859795</tei:ref>.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Allen1991" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/TV82VBVM">Allen, Ann Taylor
                  (1991): Feminism and Motherhood in Germany, 1800-1914. New Brunswick, New Jersey,
                  <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.36019/9780813571058">https://doi.org/10.36019/9780813571058</tei:ref>.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Allen2017" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/8YFRYVIH">Allen, Ann Taylor
                  (2017): The Transatlantic Kindergarten: Education and Women’s Movements in Germany
                  and the United States. New York,
                  <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190274412.001.0001">https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190274412.001.0001</tei:ref>.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Baader1996" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/PSZSTFIG">Baader, Meike Sophia
                  (1996): Die romantische Idee des Kindes und der Kindheit. Berlin. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Baader1998" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/TIDNB7QQ">Baader, Meike Sophia
                  (1998): “‘Alle wahren Demokraten tun es.’ Die Fröbelschen Kindergärten und der
                  Zusammenhang von Erziehung, Revolution und Religion”. In: Jansen,
                  Christian/Mergel, Thomas (eds.): Die Revolutionen von 1848/49:
                  Erfahrung-Verarbeitung-Deutung. Göttingen, pp. 206-225.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Baader1999" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/IJZMM8T4">Baader, Meike Sophia
                  (1999): “Die Politisierung des Fröbelschen Kindergartenprojektes durch die
                  Revolutionen von 1848/49”. In: Kemnitz, Heidemarie/Apel, Hans-Jürgen/Ritzi,
                  Christian (eds.): Bildungsideen und Schulalltag im Revolutionsjahre 1848.
                  Baltmannsweiler, pp. 51-64. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Berger2015" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/9MH88QWA">Berger, Manfred (2015):
                  Frauen in der Geschichte des Kindergartens. In: Textor, Martin R. (ed.):
                  Kindergartenpädagogik. Online Handbuch, <tei:ref target="https://www.kindergartenpaedagogik.de/fachartikel/geschichte-der-kinderbetreuung/manfred-berger-frauen-in-der-geschichte-des-kindergartens/170/">https://www.kindergartenpaedagogik.de/fachartikel/geschichte-der-kinderbetreuung/manfred-berger-frauen-in-der-geschichte-des-kindergartens/170/</tei:ref>
                  .</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Butler1999" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/RFB87RAJ">Butler, Judith (1999):
                  Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity.<tei:emph> </tei:emph>New
                  York, https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203824979.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Florvil2020" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/4M8BANUU">Florvil, Tiffany Nicole
                  (2020): Mobilizing Black Germany: Afro-German Women and the Making of a
                  Transnational Movement. Urbana, Illinois, <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.5406/j.ctv1f884c1">https://doi.org/10.5406/j.ctv1f884c1</tei:ref>. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Foyster2010" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/45E2EH29">Foyster,
                  Elizabeth/Marten, James (eds.) (2010): A Cultural History of Childhood and the
                  Family in the Age of Enlightenment.<tei:emph> </tei:emph>London.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Frevert1988" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/K3KYEWPG">Frevert, Ute (ed.)
                  (1988): Bürgerinnen und Bürger: Geschlechterverhältnisse im 19. Jahrhundert.
                  Göttingen.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Frevert1997" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/AR3YDHP4">Frevert, Ute
                     (1997):<tei:emph> </tei:emph>Women in German History: from Bourgeois
                  Emancipation to Sexual Liberation. Oxford.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Frevert2014" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/FBYC7EJM">Frevert, Ute (ed.)
                  (2014): Learning How to Feel: Children’s Literature and Emotional Socialization,
                  1870-1970. Oxford.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Fulbrook2010" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/PB3EKDL6">Fulbrook, Mary/Rublack,
                  Ulinka (2010): “In Relation: The ‘Social Self’ and Ego-Documents”. In: German
                  History 28, no. 3, pp. 263-272, <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.1093/gerhis/ghq065">https://doi.org/10.1093/gerhis/ghq065</tei:ref>.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Habermas2000" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/8NK6ELPK">Habermas, Rebekka
                  (2000): Frauen und Männer des Bürgertums: eine Familiengeschichte (1750-1850).
                  Göttingen. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Heiland2008" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/BST6KDQ5">Heiland, Helmut (2008):
                  Friedrich Fröbel in seinen Briefen. Würzburg. See also Open Access Edition
                     <tei:emph>Gesamtausgabe der Briefe Friedrich Fröbels/Complete Edition of
                     Letters by Friedich Fröbel</tei:emph> provided the BBF | Bibliothek für
                  Bildungsgeschichtliche Forschung des DIPF (ed.): <tei:ref target="https://editionen.bbf.dipf.de/exist/apps/briefedition-friedrich-froebel/index.html">https://editionen.bbf.dipf.de/exist/apps/briefedition-friedrich-froebel/index.html</tei:ref>. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Jones1971" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/UI6XDSBW">Jones, Gareth Stedman
                  (1971): Outcast London: A Study in the Relationship Between Classes in Victorian
                     Society.<tei:emph> </tei:emph>Oxford.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Kemnitz1999" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/FCIIF5YQ">Kemnitz,
                  Heidemarie/Ritzi, Christian (1999): Bildungsideen und Schulalltag im
                  Revolutionsjahr 1848. Baltmannsweiler.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Kleinau1997" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/PUS7H9ZY">Kleinau, Elke (1997):
                  Bildung und Geschlecht. Weinheim. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="König1990" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/M7QTSBF6">König, Helmut (ed.)
                  (1990): Mein Lieber Herr Fröbel! Briefe von Frauen und Jungfrauen an den Kinder
                  und Menschenfreund. Berlin.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Münchow2006" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/XAYHRYVM">Münchow, Katja (2006):
                  “The Relationship between the Kindergarten Movement, the Movement for Democracy
                  and the Early Women's Movement in the Historical Context of the Revolution of
                  1848–49, as reflected in Die Frauen‐Zeitung”. In: History of Education, vol. 35,
                  pp. 283-292, <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.1080/00467600500528677">https://doi.org/10.1080/00467600500528677</tei:ref>. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Osterhammel2014" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/8HEI7Q37">Osterhammel, Jürgen
                  (2014): The Transformation of the World: A Global History of the Nineteenth
                  Century. Princeton, <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400849949">https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400849949</tei:ref>. </tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Paletschek1990" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/B69QYKQE">Paletschek, Sylvia
                  (1990): Frauen und Dissens: Frauen im Deutschkatholizismus und in den freien
                  Gemeinden 1841-1852. Göttingen.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Pestalozzi1885" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/GIHIXECV">Pestalozzi, Johann
                  Heinrich (1885/1977): Pestalozzi’s Leonard and Gertrude,<tei:emph> </tei:emph>translated by Eva Channing. New York.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Pestalozzi1894" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/U3W4V3GQ">Pestalozzi, Johann
                  Heinrich (1894): How Gertrude Teaches Her Children: An Attempt to Help Mothers to
                  Teach Their Own Children and an Account of The Method, a Report to the Society of
                  the Friends of Education, Burgdorf,<tei:emph> </tei:emph>translated by Lucy E.
                  Holland and Francis C. Turner<tei:emph>. </tei:emph>London.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Reddy2001" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/7LRAPQAP">Reddy, William M.
                  (2001): The Navigation of Feeling a Framework for the History of Emotions.
                  Cambridge.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Rosenwein2006" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/3YJ4XDMC">Rosenwein, Barbara H.
                  (2002): “Worrying About Emotions in History”. In: The American Historical Review,
                  vol. 107, no. 3, pp. 821-845, <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.1086/ahr/107.3.821">https://doi.org/10.1086/ahr/107.3.821</tei:ref>.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Rosenwein2002" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/ELZQSYNV">Rosenwein, Barbara H.
                  (2006): Emotional Communities in the Early Middle Ages. Ithaca, New
                  York.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Rousseau1979" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/CDYTNCY5">Rousseau, Jean-Jacques
                  (1979): Emile or On Education. Introduction, Translation, and Notes by Allan
                  Bloom. New York.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Scott1986" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/7LC6653V">Scott, Joan Wallach
                  (1986): “Gender: A Useful Category of Historical Analysis”. In: The American
                  Historical Review vol. 91, no. 5, pp. 1053-1075.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Scheer2012" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/RRYCEVYF">Scheer, Monique (2012):
                  “Are Emotions a Kind of Practice (And is That What Makes Them Have a History)? A
                  Bourdieuian Approach to Understanding Emotion”. In: History and Theory, vol. 51,
                  no. 2, pp. 193-220, <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2303.2012.00621.x">https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2303.2012.00621.x</tei:ref>.</tei:bibl>
               <tei:bibl xml:id="Wasmuth2020" corresp="http://zotero.org/groups/4596542/items/M48EJWN2">Wasmuth, Helge (2020):
                  Fröbel’s Pedagogy of Kindergarten and Play: Modifications in Germany and the
                  United States. New York, <tei:ref target="https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429059278">https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429059278</tei:ref>.</tei:bibl>
            </tei:listBibl>
         </tei:div>
      </tei:back>
   </tei:text>
</tei:TEI>